As the American Sniper trial begins, should PTSD be used as a defense?

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

STEPHENVILLE, Texas -- The "American Sniper" trial begins in Stephenville. Eddie Ray Routh, charged with murdering Chris Kyle and Chad Littlefield, pled not guilty.

Kyle, the former Navy SEAL, whose best-selling book later became the hit movie "American Sniper."

Routh's defense, insanity due to post traumatic stress disorder, prompts a country to revisit, should PTSD be allowed to be used as part of a defense for murder.

Professor Geoffrey Corn of South Texas College of Law explained, "He has a lawyer, the lawyer has an ethical obligation to do the very best he can to defend this guy. This is the only ammunition in the lawyer`s magazine, there`s no other way to defend him."

But some, who have served in the military, don`t quite agree.

Terry Arcuri, a former Marine, said, "I think it`s a cop-out, I mean everybody has stress in their lives, and especially a lot of veterans coming home, have a lot of associated with their deployments but it doesn`t mean that you should be able to necessarily use that stress and anxiety to act out in inappropriate ways."

Adrian Canizares who served in the U.S. Navy adds,  "No, I don`t think they should allow him to use PTSD as a defense. I`d rather him claim insanity."

"I think what we are more likely to see is that they`re going to offer evidence of the PTSD as an indication there was a deeper mental problem," added Corn.

As we watch the trial progress, we`ll see if PTSD will help Routh's defense, or if it's just a shot in the dark.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.